Wednesday, April 8, 2009

Too Big to Fail: Antitrust law


When I heard the words “to big to fail,” about AIG, I immediately thought of antitrust law. When an organization becomes so big that it controls a market, it is called a monopoly. The US government then regulates it or divides these “trusts” through the work of the Federal Trade Commission, Bureau of Competition or the Attorney General’s office, Antitrust division. The FTC and the Attorney General’s office promote competition by reviewing and approving mergers and by taking court action against companies engaged in prohibitive practices. These offices work through two basic laws, the Sherman Antitrust Act (1890) and the Clayton Antitrust Act (1914). Most of us know little about this rather esoteric part of law, but it actually affects us much more than Supreme Court cases about our civil liberties or rights. You may be vaguely familiar with the term trust busting from recalling the history of President Teddy Roosevelt’s effort to “trustbust,” break the monopoly power of the railroads. In New England we are seeing the result of anti-trust law as ExxonMobil divests itself of gasoline stations to other companies.


Monopolies can be caused by vertical or horizontal integration. In vertical integration, a company buys up all its suppliers or inter-related businesses. In horizontal integration, it buys up its competitors. The theory is that a monopoly can set prices and control the market. In a nutshell antitrust law determines if prohibitive practices are taking place. Some monopolies have been allowed in the past particularly in the utilities area (telephone, electricity) and banking. State laws contributed to monopolies of commercial banks, credit unions, savings and loans by regulating their practices to be contained within a state. Some competition existed between the three, but all in all they had distinct purposes: to provide financial services to companies and then to individuals, to providing checking, savings and loans to member employees of particular companies, and to provide savings and loan services to individuals primarily for homes, respectively.


What struck me as odd was the government involvement in creating the mergers of huge failing banks and private banks (banks that are unregulated and are not publicly traded). The government did not seek to divide these “too big to fail” banks but to merge them creating possible monopoly power.


What is the AG’s office and the FTC doing? The FTC’s website warns the public of “phising” emails from emailers pretending to be affiliated with these new banks, and the FTC provides information on deceptive mortgage practices. But only as of this week did it announce a crackdown on these practices. The Attorney General’s (AG) website has bank merger Guidelines (April 2, 1992) and an explanation of those guidelines given at a banking conference (1996). The AG’s office has primary responsibility for bank mergers. The site says nothing about the recent bank merger activities that have been reported in the press.


The AG’s office reviews banks in terms of the effect on local market competition, the share of deposits and loans, compared to other banks in the area assessing horizontal monopoly effects. So antitrust activity related to banks is stuck in an era when the location of a bank had more meaning. In the era of cross-state, international, and web banks; international private banks; and non-banks acting as banks (finance companies, mortgage companies, credit card companies), this is a limited means to assess competition.


AIG is a different antitrust problem and less clear. It is actually an umbrella of 130 businesses including insurance companies, retirement funds (VALIC), financial products (Financial Products ), mortgage underwriting company (Mortgage Capital) and an aircraft leasing company (International Lease). It’s possible that its many businesses create a vertical monopoly.


In both the banking and AIG cases, the FTC and AG have been quiet (although they may be involved behind the scenes). What the public does see is whether called banks or not, these entities are inter-related and as one goes down another goes down. In this sense, anti-trust laws and their regulatory rules need to be updated for the global world of banking. Or we need a better model that moves away from the fear of large companies and regulates where minimal competition exists. European countries, in theory, regulate the action of the monopolies rather than “busting” them. But it appears that the European model has failed as well with little oversight of the large banks of, say, England or Iceland.

Wednesday, March 25, 2009

What is transparency and AIG?

In the aftermath of Watergate in the 1970s, a number of laws were enacted giving the public greater access to governmental information, increasing the accountability of businesses, civil servants and politicians for their actions, and making decisions more open. These included the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA), the Sunshine in Government Act (1976), and the Presidential Records Act (1978) giving the press and the public access to many government documents on request, to most meetings, and to many presidential materials.

Today these pieces of legislation might be described as creating transparency. The President, state’s attorneys general (Connecticut/New York), the appointee to oversee the bank bailout (Neil M. Barofsky), Republicans and Democrats, and journalists call for greater transparency, particularly when it comes to banks and AIG. But what do they mean?

Transparency is a relatively common word in the parlance of nongovernmental organizations and supranational organizations (e.g., European Union, Organization for Economic and Co-operative Development, and the International Monetary Fund). It is a word used to convey an open process, a way of conducting business that is subject to public scrutiny to reduce the possibility of corruption.

Its institutionalization may have caught on by an accident of translation assuming that the German, French, and English meaning of Transparenz, transparence, and transparency are similar. But it also became prominent when during the early 1990s, Peter Eigen, a manager at the World Bank, became increasingly distressed by the Bank’s failure to address corruption in its loan-giving to nations. Mr. Eigen with a small group of individuals created Transparency International. The organization would examine the effects and consequences of corruption for citizens, report on it across nations, and advocate policy changes in global institutions to address corrupt practices. Today, the organization has affiliates throughout the world, publishes a Corruption Index, and has developed a National Integrity System promoting open structures in the media, business, government, and throughout all of society.

Transparency International’s mission may not mean much to the average American. Corruption is an issue, but not one at the top of the agenda. Instead transparency may mean a piece of film that you write on to project on a screen. Or it could mean accountability. Often politicians use accountability and transparency in the same sentence, not really distinguishing between the two. Legislation such as the Federal Funding Accountability and Transparency Act of 2006 and the Legislative Transparency and Accountability section of the Honest Leadership and Open Government Act of 2007 use the word transparency side by side with accountability. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) enacted a new reporting form for nonprofits to increase accountability and transparency.

But more and more it is coming to mean ready public access to government, nonprofit, and business information. With the newness of the idea of transparency, the confusion over its many meanings, and the tug for privacy and secrecy, politicians, banks, and AIG ignored creating transparency. Congress, the Treasury Secretary, and bank officials and most recently AIG learned the lesson of transparency when Congress failed to put in legal requirements, the Treasury Secretary failed to provide oversight for reporting the use of bailout funds and employee bonuses, and bank and AIG officials were not forthcoming with that information. A chance to increase the trust of the public was lost. Transparency is different from simple accountability because it creates trust directly. AIG’s web site has its executive compensation committee, its annual report, but it fails in describing its most important relationship, its relationship to the public.

Maybe AIG is too big to fail as the press is stating, but certainly not invincible from shaming. But perhaps there is another problem that needs to be addressed. If AIG and some of the banks are too big to fail, when is the Federal Trade Commission or the United States Attorney General going to investigate these businesses in terms of anti-trust laws?

Wednesday, March 4, 2009

Planning a City: Dubai

I just got back from the ultimate planned city and country, Dubai, United Arab Emirates. The state received its independence in 1968 and began serious building in the mid '70s when it built a world trade center in the desert. Rotaries were built to nowhere planning for future growth.) Of course, we have a few planned communities and certainly in India and China new communities are springing up.

What would you do if you could build up from nothing?

Two conflicting views make planning cities difficult. One view is that a city is best that is diverse in people, in business, and in residences. In the world according to Jane Jacobs and others, we are safer when the factory, the deli, the park and our homes and apartments are in the same general location. We watch for each other. The other view of non-planners is that we don't want to live where we work.

Dubai has chosen the latter view but with a lot of planning. There are all sorts of special areas, for sports, for hotels, and for specific industries. I travelled through an area that was all automotive related with car parts stores, tires piled high, and places to buy rebuilt engines and auto parts.

I specifically visited Dubai Healthcare City, a planned area in which the state of art ideas, construction, and equipment will be used to make world-class healthcare available in the Mid-east. What's more it will be provided by a diverse array of professionals from all over the world. It is impressive. Yes, there will be a few shops for eating, obtaining prescriptions in the first phase, but it will largely be a place to go for excellent healthcare. Later there will be some housing and a mosque will follow. The state expects this "free zone" to devise the highest standards. To do so, Dubai Healthcare City created its own Center for Healthcare Planning and Quality (CPQ) to regulate the facilities and professions. One hospital is already in operation through Welcare, a South African company. And Boston University has enrolled its first class of dentists who will be getting advanced degrees and certificates in specialty areas. Harvard is working with DHC to build a teaching and research hospital.

During my time there, I met Indians, Pakistanis, Egyptians, Brits, South Africans, Filipinos, Iraqis, Palestinians, and UAE citizens all working to create the highest international standard of healthcare borrowing from the regulatory environment of the US, the Commonwealth Countries, and a few others. Twenty one countries have good enough programs in medicine, nursing and allied health to have professionals work in Dubai Healthcare City. Even then, some programs in these countries may not meet the standards being created. Nurses must, for example, have at least two years recent experience before they will be accepted for a job in healthcare city.

The other amazing part is that two languages are being used, Arabic and English and so employees must be fluent in one or the other, and most often both. In a predominately Muslim country, health professionals will likely be Catholic (from the Philippines), Hindu and Muslim (from India), and Christian (from the US and Commonwealth countries, and Muslim from states throughout the Mideast and Africa.

Still, there is a downside. Planning is always illusive. Separating out various industries from living areas means that cars and traffic are a major problem. Today, Dubai is building a monorail. The first test runs were being conducted as I visited.
And no bookstore area exists! I never did find a bookstore and I wanted desperately to get a book about their architecture, all of it built in the last 40 years. Even the hotels did not have kiosks with romance novels. Where were the bookstores?

Friday, February 13, 2009

Furloughs and Other Cost Savings in Government and Nonprofits

Governor Schwarzenegger made headlines announcing that state offices including the Department of Motor Vehicles would have to take every other Friday off to save money. No one can doubt the savings. The problem is the method. DMVs in many states have improved their customer service greatly, but others are known for their distinct lack of customer care. Finding the door closed every other Friday is going to anger the public. If two days off each month is necessary, and I have no doubt that it is a flexible furlough where employees choose the day they take off helps retain customer service and give employees some control over a very difficult time. (The governor may indeed be building in savings of reducing heating or air conditioning on those days.)


Governor Schwarzenegger is not alone in furloughing employees. In most service organizations, the cost of employees is the major cost of doing business. Furloughing is a very reasonable idea. The reduction in pay is relatively small for the state employee. If you assume that about 1/3 of the pay for every 8 hours is taken up in taxes, then for every $100 an employee earns, they are losing $66.00. And even then they are continuing to earn their vacation, health insurance, sick-time, pension and that the same rate they normally do. Benefits including mandated benefits such as worker’s comp and unemployment insurance constitute about 30% of the salary in the private sector (somewhat less for nonprofits) and 34% for the public sector according to the Department of Labor. That is for every $100 the employee earns, benefits may cost the employer another $30 to $34. So during those days off the employee is still earning.


But in the long run, governments and nonprofits may want to look at institutionalizing “furloughs.” In one hospital I worked in, it was called vacation without pay. Most offices have down times. That often occurs around the holidays when yes, employees would like more money to pay for Christmas and other gifts, but they also need time off to run errands. Institutionalizing vacation without pay or low need time policies makes good sense, particularly as we continue to worry about an aging, expensive workforce. Baby boomers are the individuals who might want to take time off voluntarily. Or this can be institutionalized as part of reverse seniority systems, asking the most senior people if they would like to take time off first. Again, benefits are still registered as though the employee was still working. Some organizations such as universities are slower in the summer, others in the winter. Employees can be encouraged to take “vacation without pay” during those times.


Another possibility that will save much more money is to change the workweek. Most of us work a 40 hour work week. There is no reason that the work week can’t be 39 hours, getting off one hour early on Friday, or 371/2 hours, or even 35 hours. I have seen the effectiveness of thirty-seven and one-half work weeks even in hospitals, organizations with shift work. The traditional shifts require a costly half-hour overlap, 7-3:30PM, 3-11:30PM, 11-7:30AM. In the 37 ½ hour scenario, employees do need to be responsible and call in early if they are going to be late or are ill, but this is not unreasonable. If there are real concerns that this would make salaries uncompetitive (probably not a concern during the economic downturn), then benefits can be computed as though the person worked the traditional work week.


In the end, these changes to wages and hours must be negotiated in unionized workforces as is the case for most government agencies and increasingly in nonprofit hospitals. But this is not insurmountable. And these ideas are much more palatable than the temporary reduction in pay mandated by Maryland state government. Union members want to keep their jobs and they want the organization to succeed. Fairness is the key and government, hospital executives, and other nonprofit executives may wish to demonstrate their support by taking vacation without pay or voluntarily cutting back pay to the equivalent of the 37 ½ work week.

Sunday, February 8, 2009

Pay and Wall Street Executives



The news has been filled with discussion of Walt Street executive bonuses. Each of these executives received their bonuses even though their companies were failing and now receive special federal government funds. The executives have been attacked for the huge size of their bonuses, but the attack is probably misplaced. It is the boards of these companies that deserve our criticisms. They make the decision how to compensate executives. Once the form of bonus is determined and how it is to be earned, these boards are contractually obligated to provide these bonuses.


Of course, the boards could have tried to renegotiate, and, of course, the executives could have offered to not take the bonuses. But neither took place.


The reason for providing these bonuses, at least as portrayed to the public, is bonuses are needed to retain these executives. Many on Wall Street are underpaid, comparatively speaking, to other executives, and the bonuses make up for low pay. But there’s the rub. Bonuses are supposed to be a form of pay for performance. The better you do for the company the more money in stocks and cash you are paid. Thus, the more successful the company is, the more of a bonus the exec should be paid. So if a company is going under, then the exec should receive nothing.


The Board shouldn’t want to retain the executive. There is no need for a retention bonus nor a bonus to make up for lower pay. Surely, there are other employees in the company or in another company who might like the opportunity to bring back the company from this down time.


Bonuses or other forms of pay for performance do tend to make people work hard, at least initially, but then employees grow to expect them year after year. They become complacent. The bonus has to increase and increase spiraling well beyond what will motivate, if indeed it is motivating. Given that these bonuses seem to be largely unrelated to how well the company is doing, they are incredibly absurd as an incentive for these Wall Street executives.


It is time that boards begin to recognize what they are doing and take responsibility. They have a fiduciary responsibility to manage the company properly. Though those of us looking on must feel these bonuses are immoral and unethical, it is likely that the executives feel some guilt about receiving these bonuses, but after the guilt begins to diminish, I’m sure they are busy spending them and expecting to receive another next year. Given that we have not heard of boards taking responsibility for this financial mess and executives giving back pay, it may very well be that the future legislation must micro manage and figure out means to restrict bonuses. When a government agency does wrong a consent decree is established giving a court appointee representative the right to oversee the activities of the agency. This is an extreme response, but maybe we do need an appointee to work with these boards to help them understand their responsibilities to their shareholders and the public.

Wednesday, January 21, 2009

Change and President Obama

President Barack Obama campaigned on the idea of change. But really what is it? In his acceptance speech at the Democratic convention, he used the word change 12 times. He defined change as progress. Progress is something that can be measured—-jobs created, mortgages paid, new businesses starting. It is also specific actions of government: ending dependence upon oil in 10 years, tax code changes to favor small business and business that created jobs here rather than shipping them abroad, ending programs that don’t work, enabling equal pay for equal work. “Change comes to Washington” when people demand it, not from Washington.


At his inaugural, the word change did not really come up except in a grander sense. “For the world has changed, and we must change with it.” Still the idea of change was there. It still can be measured in jobs and in eliminating programs that don’t work. Oddly now change is more ill defined because we are in a crisis. One would think a crisis would require even more concrete ideas But the crisis has caused “[l]ess measurable but no less profound”…a sapping of confidence across our land - a nagging fear that America's decline is inevitable, and that the next generation must lower its sights.


As in the change of his acceptance speech, the change of President Obama’s inaugural speech requires a change in the character of politics so people can disagree without character aspersions. This may be laudable, but that is not how politics work. We choose parties and our representatives because they have different views of the world. Disagreement and attacks are the stuff of politics, at least the public side. Within Congress it is surprising how many senators and representatives are friends despite conflicting opinions. And those conflicting opinions often are the backbone of compromise. I’ll give you this, if you give me that. And, in truth, many, many bills are passed with bi-partisan support.


Each president is faced with new difficulties that require new policies—that is change. President Obama is not unique in calling for change. The change he speaks of is a change that public administrators love, one that can be measured. At the same time, he recognizes that politics will play hand. That is people’s opinions, their feeling of confidence for the nation and his leadership will affect what he can do to rally Congress to implement new laws and changes in existing laws.

http://www.umaine.edu/pubadmin/faculty/ball.htm